When the usual candle-and-card shop isn't cutting it, 3rd Eye Gifts, Novelties, & Oddities on West 41st Street earns its name. This is the place Sioux Falls locals drag their out-of-town guests when they want to watch someone's eyes go wide.
They stock the kind of inventory that resists a clean category: metaphysical items, oddities, collectibles, and gifts that start arguments at dinner tables in the best possible way. Whether you're sourcing something genuinely strange, browsing alternative décor, or hunting a conversation piece for someone who claims they're impossible to shop for — this store tends to solve that problem.
The west-side location flies a little under the radar, which seems fitting. People who find it tend to come back, and they bring someone new. It's not curated for mass appeal, and that's exactly the point. If you want something nobody else at the party will have, this is where you look.